![mac ui design mac ui design](https://blog.tubikstudio.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/SwiftyBeaver_UX-design.png)
#Mac ui design mac
Morgan’s complaints about the Mac App Store app and his initial remarks about Twitter are of the conservative variety: non-standard windows and UI elements are wrong. It’s been renamed from “Tweetie” to “Twitter”, but the version number has gone to 2.0 because what we have today is the next version of the same app. It’s all set in Helvetica (like iOS apps), not Lucida Grande (like Mac apps).īut let’s also be clear about where the app is coming from: Loren Brichter’s Tweetie for Mac:īrichter, now a full-time employee of Twitter, is still the app’s primary developer. You drag the window using that black sidebar. Completely custom close/minimize/zoom buttons (which ignore your system-wide settings for color no red/yellow/green for you). To be clear, here’s the app we’re talking about: The problem is that once you see that a certain piece of UI criticism is coming from someone at a distant position from yours on the conservative/liberal design spectrum, there’s a natural tendency to close your mind and discount everything they say. “This isn’t good design” criticisms, however, if accurate, are the sort of thing most designers ought to agree with, regardless of their position on the conservative/liberal UI design spectrum. “Agreed, that’s wrong” say the conservatives. “ This is non-standard” criticisms will thus generate one of two responses. Liberals see an app built using nothing other than standard system UI elements as boring, old-fashioned, stodgy.
![mac ui design mac ui design](https://cdn.dribbble.com/users/92173/screenshots/14114200/media/168f7d0ccdb9641840ff3c6075069051.png)
The conservatives see non-standard custom UI elements as wrong.
![mac ui design mac ui design](https://img.indiefolio.com/fit-in/1100x0/filters:format(webp):fill(transparent)/project/body/1993ce24c8a230c5a002f1f0bdc783b2.png)
There’s a conservative/liberal sort of fork in UI design, in the sense of traditional/non-traditional. (Or, to be honest, at least not only why.) It’s simply that when you read Morgan’s piece - and if you haven’t already, you should as soon as you finish this sentence - it’s worth keeping in mind which of his criticisms fall under “this is non-standard” and which fall under “this isn’t good design”. That but sounds dismissive, like I’m using it to say that his criticism, no matter how accurate, can be dismissed, because he still subscribes to a set of standards from a bygone era. I spent a few minutes there trying to think of a way to rewrite the preceding sentence without that but.
#Mac ui design for mac
This piece today by Tim Morgan offers a detailed and thoughtful critique of the Mac App Store titlebar/toolbar and the new Twitter for Mac - but it’s a critique from the perspective of a critic who still believes in HIG-rooted uniformity. (No one but Apple could have made Brushed Metal popular.) Apple sets the tone, for better or for worse. Whether this change has been for better or for worse is certainly debatable, but there can be no debate that the mores of Mac UI designers have changed.
#Mac ui design mac os
In Mac OS X, Apple began experimenting - especially in their flagship apps. In Mac OS 9 (and prior), no one’s apps were more uniformly consistent to the HIG standards than Apple’s own. A perusal through the early DF archives will show that. I used to have a fervor for uniform consistency in Mac UI design. The new Twitter for Mac is somewhat polarizing, what with its almost entirely custom UI. Individuality in Mac UI Design Friday, 7 January 2011